virtualization.tv is coming...

VMware to release ESX 3i for free next week

Tuesday, July 22, 2008   |   19 Comments   |   addthis

VMware finally made the move that everybody predicted and was awaited for a long time: releasing its hypervisor for free.

During the Q2 2008 earnings call the company announced that before the end of July (the planned date is July 28) it will release the Update 2 for VMware Infrastructure 3.5 and that will give away the lightweight edition of the product, ESX 3i, for free.

The new 3i edition was introduced at the end of the last year.
It doesn’t change the characteristics of the hypervisor but fundamentally chances a part of its architecture, dropping the Console Operating System (COS) and reducing the overall system footprint to 32Mb.
The change allowed several OEMs to preload this edition of the hypervisor into their servers, through internal USB keys, Solid-State Drives (SSD) or hidden partition in the primary hard drives.

virtualization.info has learned some additional details about the move:

  • VI 3.5 and ESX 3i will continue to share a the large majority of the code base (so there will be an ESX 3i Update 2). There will be no delays on the release of both products.
  • ESX 3i will continue to have the same features that has today, without additional limitations
  • ESX 3i will continue to have the same APIs, allowing anybody to develop free or commercial alternatives to VirtualCenter (despite some features like VMotion cannot be replicated because of the VMware SDK limitations).
  • VMware will not require the purchase of any software & support subscription to access the product. Customer will be able to get the code without any restriction.
  • The customers that purchased the current version of ESX 3i directly from the VMware online store will be eligible for a rebate.
  • The ESX version that includes the Console Operating System (COS) will not be faded out (at least in the short timeframe). Most VMware customers are currently using that version and the company will support them for a long time.
  • VMware Server will not be faded out (as many could suppose). The company still sees the product as a valuable proposition for a different kind of audience.

At first sight this move seems a clear attempt to recover the terrible stock performance that VMware is suffering from the departure of its former CEO Diane Greene.
But virtualization.info has learned that the plan was not developed by the new CEO Paul Maritz, but by Greene herself several months ago.

How the free ESX will impact the market?

First of all, the competition will move on the virtual infrastructure management (with a special focus on the storage) and automation (for hosted desktops, virtual labs, VM lifecycle, autonomous computing, cloud computing) areas, turning the hypervisor as a commodity, embedded in the operating system or not.
Any vendor that will not adopt the same strategy (like Citrix or Virtual Iron) will have a hard time to justify the price of its solution.

Secondarily, the product will finally boost the diffusion of VMware technologies in the SMB market.
This will seriously disturb the Microsoft effort in this space and all the other virtualization vendors that have a clear focus on the small companies (like Virtual Iron or Parallels).

Last but not least, the sales channel will become critical to win the competition for most customers.
When multiple market leaders have a similar proposition in terms of price and feature set, the experience in managing the channel does the real difference.
VMware didn’t seem able to compete with Microsoft and Citrix here, but the new CEO certainly has the knowledge to correct the mistakes of the past.

19 Comments

Anonymous Joe Precious Wednesday, July 23, 2008 3:11:00 PM  
This is a very welcome bit of news, although not entirely unexpected. I've not had any exposure to the ESX line yet due to costs, so I'll definitely be downloading this.

We've been testing both Xen and Hyper-V and it will be very interesting to see how this compares to them. Given how long VMWare have been producing hypervisor based products, I would expect it to be a very mature product.
Anonymous Jason Boche Wednesday, July 23, 2008 3:42:00 PM  
I really like this move. For many months the competition has aimed their blog comments and marketing departments at VMware's "steep" pricing, ignoring TCO calculations and not recognizing the tangible value that years of VMware R&D bring to the table for businesses and end users.
Anonymous Anonymous Wednesday, July 23, 2008 4:27:00 PM  
Also agree this sounds good, but I guess the free Esx3i version will still be very picky about what kind of hardware it installs on? Although Hyper-V is not perfect either as servers have to be 64bit.
Anonymous Anonymous Wednesday, July 23, 2008 5:35:00 PM  
IMHO, Being very picky about hardware is a good thing for an enterprise architecture building block.

If you want to play with any old commodity hardware, there is always VMware Server.
Anonymous Daniel_uk Wednesday, July 23, 2008 9:06:00 PM  
Remember we will be still charged for the add on features...so this is sly
Anonymous Anonymous Wednesday, July 23, 2008 9:31:00 PM  
This is an exceedingly good piece of news. With a much more mature hypervisor available for free, it does not make sense for anyone to opt for XEN /Hyper-V now. Also, the value proposition that VMware has for its end users in terms of rich product portfolio is unmatched in terms of quality..!
Anonymous Anonymous Wednesday, July 23, 2008 10:33:00 PM  
FYI: ESX 3i will NOT require x64bit HW.

I have it running on a Dell PowerVault 775N
odd, Dual Proc, 2.8GHz 32bit Xeon.

Of course you need x64bit HW to run x64bit VMs.
Anonymous Steve Wednesday, July 23, 2008 10:58:00 PM  
While this looks really good and will hopefully be a good replacement for standalone VMWare Servers...

This will only be of any *real* use if they
throw in the VirtualCenter agent! Or at least make it the same price as the VirtualCenter Agent for VMWare Server!

If we have to buy minimum Foundation edition for list $995 - then there is no real advantage!
Anonymous Mark Wilson Thursday, July 24, 2008 3:50:00 PM  
Responding to the anonymous commenter above, Why is 64-bit hardware an issue? Any decent server from the last few years has a 64-bit CPU, even if you've been using it for a 32-bit OS until now.

And anything older is probably not a good choice for a virtualisation host anyway!
Anonymous Anonymous Thursday, July 24, 2008 3:53:00 PM  
Actually you can't buy Foundation for just $995, it's bundled with support contract. The minimum you have to spend is $1540. On the bright side, you can always skip VC altogether.
Anonymous Anonymous Thursday, July 24, 2008 6:08:00 PM  
responding to the skip VC altogether and the 'sly' comment:
1. can't really skip VC because it's required for all the other good features like HA, VMotion, Update Manager, etc. It's VMware's form of vendor lock-in.
2. 'sly' is a good way to put it...one does have to pay for a lot of useful features, VMware really should drop the price for VC and the basic features like HA and VMotion...
Anonymous Steve Thursday, July 24, 2008 8:02:00 PM  
Sorry Mark you are quite right - forgot about the mandatory support.

At the moment we pay £75 + support for a two-CPU license for VC agent for VMware Server, so if ESX 3i won't come with a similar offering, it's not much use to us. It's very useful to have VC without HA/DRS/VMotion just for being bale to move VMs between hosts and use NAS storage for templates etc - however it is not worth $1500 per server!
Anonymous Anonymous Thursday, July 24, 2008 10:47:00 PM  
No one has said much about the Update 2. I'm just curious if this update will include support for Windows 2008?
Anonymous Paul Friday, July 25, 2008 7:55:00 AM  
They are all being a bit "sly"

The alternative is selling theirs for $28 just to get around EU rulings that prevent them for giving away for free, so they can sell you an Operating System that you may not need to eventually sell you their management suite and a service contract.
Anonymous Anonymous Friday, July 25, 2008 8:10:00 AM  
This is good news, now i can get something for free and not pay over $500! Good work VMware!
Anonymous Anonymous Friday, July 25, 2008 8:55:00 AM  
@Steve: You don't need the Virtual Center agent to manage ESXi with the VI client. HostAgent does just fine. The VC agent (vpxa) is only pushed to the machine once you add it to a VC deployment.
Anonymous Anonymous Friday, July 25, 2008 1:56:00 PM  
This move is irrelevant to the Enterprise customer. What good is having a non-VC managed ESX box? Maybe a lab. When they make DRS, HA, VMotion for $1000 then they will have something! Otherwise $500 is nothing based on our discounts and volume. This is a lot of fluff! (Of course I will use it at home!)
Anonymous Jason Boche Saturday, July 26, 2008 12:17:00 AM  
Listening to some of the comments, some of you expect VMware to give away most everything for free. You don't see Microsoft giving away hot migration for free do you? VMware is now in alignment with Microsoft and has leveled the playing field on price. Give VMware a break. They are giving away the hypervisor for free now - it's what the industry has been predicting would happen. How do you expect them to be a viable business by giving away everything for free including their management tools? Why don't you go to work for free for a while and see how that works out for paying your mortgage and other necessities.
Anonymous Anonymous Wednesday, July 30, 2008 4:10:00 PM  
Are there any news about "The customers that purchased the current version of ESX 3i directly from the VMware online store will be eligible for a rebate." ?

Add New Comment